CRO Experts Guide to Effective Conversion Rate Optimization Best Practices

Search through blog
Table of Contents
CRO Experts Guide to Effective Conversion Rate Optimization Best Practices, SyncSpider Blog

Sometimes, we pull up a chair with those who’ve been in the eCommerce game for longer than most of us. With the world turning topsy-turvy, we all wondered, “How do we get those conversion rates to climb?” Well, here’s the real talk from those who’ve been there and done that.

This isn’t just a roundup; it’s a cozy chat over digital coffee, a chance to peek into the notebooks of eCommerce gurus. Ready to find out their trade secrets? Let’s dive in together.

Prioritize understanding your customers

Matt Janaway, CEO of Marketing Labs, a well-established digital marketing agency, advises you to focus on your customers.

Matt Janaway, CEO of Marketing Labs, Expert Round, Prioritize understanding your customers

“One of the successful strategies we’ve used to boost the conversion rates of our clients is ensuring that product presentations are top-notch. We’ve found that when product images and descriptions are clear, detail-oriented, and high-quality, users tend to trust the products and are more likely to convert. Additionally, we encourage clients to provide a diverse range of secure and convenient payment options on a mobile-friendly website. This enables customers to shop from any device, adding to a seamless online shopping experience, which results in higher conversion rates.

We use AI and machine learning algorithms to offer personalised product recommendations based on customers’ shopping histories and preferences. This helps us both in upselling and cross-selling. In addition to AI, we use tools like Google Analytics and heat maps to examine intricate patterns of user behaviour, find where potential customers might be dropping off, and identify areas of our website that need improvement to boost conversions.

A particular instance that stands out is when we rebuilt a client website with a particular focus on expanding the pages based on keyword intent. Alongside other SEO work and link-building campaigns, we increased their enquiries by 502% within 12 months.

Implementing these strategies was by no means an easy process. The initial phase involved remodelling the website, conducting a thorough examination and pinpointing key areas to enhance the site’s design, functionality, and usability. A particular emphasis was put on the user experience, from their first interaction with the brand through to the conversion funnel.

In addition to design enhancements, the project also included considerable SEO work. Future-focused, we fused the brand’s unique tone with optimised content for improved search engine visibility. We found hundreds of opportunities for new pages that align their services perfectly with what people are searching for.

As our partnership with them grew stronger, we expanded our assistance by devising a comprehensive digital marketing approach and implementing a variety of digital marketing strategies. In the initial stages, our work was primarily focused on SEO and external link profile enhancement, driving fantastic results.

With the strategy’s success and the company’s growth, we broadened the scope of our services to include multiple digital marketing channels, such as Google Ads advertising using Meta platforms, a robust content marketing approach, and an email program to bolster customer retention.

For PPC, we started by identifying keywords most relevant to their core business services. These aligned with the new pages we created. Given the localised business nature, geographical targeting was crucial. Once set up, we launched discovery and display campaigns to increase brand recognition and boost familiarity, in addition to promoting key offers and services. We took a similar approach with paid socials to extend audience reach and strengthen brand familiarity.

Following the implementation of the revamped strategy, they have experienced remarkable growth, not only with significant improvements in keyword ranking and web traffic but a whopping 500% increase in enquiry rates, underscoring the real-life impact and success of the upgraded plan.

eCommerce businesses aiming to enhance their conversion rates need to prioritise understanding their customers. This means both gathering and analysing data about customers’ shopping habits and feedback and leveraging these insights to offer personalised experiences.

This could come in many forms: from suggesting products based on previous shopping experiences to simply knowing a customer’s name. Additionally, place emphasis on user convenience — easy navigation, quick load times, and diverse payment methods should be a given. Lastly, fostering excellent customer service may seem basic, but customer service is crucial in not only converting customers but retaining them as well.

Delighting customers at every touchpoint and resolving their issues promptly will build their trust and loyalty..”

Less is More – Content Removal for Conversion Rate Optimization

Jared Bauman, the co-founder of 201 Creative and the host of Niche Pursuits, strongly advises focusing on SEO and content removal.

Jared Bauman, co-founder of 201 Creative, Expert Round, Less is More - Content Removal for Conversion Rate Optimization

At my agency, we helped an online clothing store spike traffic by 867% and sales by 291% through targeted content cuts. Chopping unrelated articles diluted authority. We re-focused on their core product. Traffic and revenue tanked, then exploded after rebuilding authority content. But it took serious patience – over a year for gains.

Moral: With the right strategy, deleting content can supersize relevance. But it’s a long play, not a quick fix.”

CRO Tip: Perfection doesn’t sell. Transparency converts.

Todd Caponi, a published author and founder of Sales Melon LLC, has an exciting story regarding conversion rate.

Todd Caponi, founder of Sales Melon LLC, Expert Round, CRO Tip: Perfection doesn't sell. Transparency converts

“In my last role, I was the Chief Revenue Officer of an eCommerce technology provider called PowerReviews. In 2016, we engaged with Northwestern University on a study simply looking at consumer behavior for brands and retailers. The results were pretty mind-blowing. I mean, like a lunatic, I quit my job and wrote a book!

The first data point, and no surprise, was that we all look at reviews when we’re buying something we’ve never bought before that’s of medium-to-high consideration. (i.e., more than a pack of gum)

However, the next two data points were the mind-blowers as it relates to e-commerce conversion.

  1.  85% of us go to negative reviews first. We skip the 5s and read the 4s, 3s, 2s, and 1s first.
  2. The optimal average review star rating for conversation was between a 4.2-4.5 (on a 5-star scale).

This average was across all product categories (some skewed higher, some a little lower), but the point being, a product with negative reviews right under will sell at a higher conversion rate than a product with nothing but perfect 5-star reviews. As a matter of fact, recent research has shown that a product with nothing but perfect 5-star reviews sells at about the same conversion rate as a product with an average review score of ~ 3.25.

Perfection doesn’t sell. Transparency converts.

We, as human beings, need to be able to predict to trigger a purchase decision. We don’t buy when we’re convinced. The top e-commerce providers do everything they can to help their customers predict by making it easy to assess both the pros… and the CONS.

As it turns out, this same phenomenon applies to B2B or human-to-human sales. When salespeople are willing to share and lead with what their solution gives up to be great at its core, decision cycles speed up, win rates go up, time is better spent, and competitors are disarmed.”

Optimize Website: Back to the Basics

Erin Banta, co-founder of Pepper, a unique E-commerce site that provides sustainable, custom-made home goods at affordable prices, says that we need to go back to basics.

Erin Banta, co-founder of Pepper, Expert Round, Optimize Website: Back to the Basics

“If you want to boost your conversion rates, remember to go back to the basics. For example, your website should be clean, aesthetically pleasing, and user-friendly. The closer to these qualities your website is, the higher your conversion rate will be. Especially with so many options for customers, it’s imperative that you make the shopping and purchasing process simple, easy, and straightforward.

If what they’re looking for isn’t right in front of their eyes and readily available, you might see high levels of cart abandonment. Things like suggested items or recently viewed items will help to streamline the customer experience and make your website more desirable from start to finish.”

A mix of traditional best practices & innovative approach

Abhi Bavishi, a growth marketer and automation expert with more than seven years of experience in eCommerce, advises:
“Navigating the choppy waters of eCommerce is a challenge I’ve relished since my company’s inception. Our conversion rate improvement strategies have been a mix of traditional best practices and innovative, bespoke methods.

Abhi Bavishi, Expert Round, A mix of traditional best practices & innovative approach

One strategy that yielded significant results was employing predictive analysis—an AI-driven tool. Historically, we were reliant on retargeting ads. However, we found personalization driven by predictive analysis dramatically enhanced our ability to convert customers on their first visits. The tool analyzes customers’ behavior during their first visits and displays strategically customized landing pages and recommendations. This led to a 15% increase in our conversion rates.

Of course, integrating AI wasn’t without hiccups. The undertaking required training staff to use new tools, deal with data privacy issues, and convince stakeholders of the investment. We surmounted these hurdles through extensive staff training sessions, strict adherence to GDPR and CCPA regulations, and thorough pilot testing before completing the integration.

For other eCommerce businesses aiming to enhance conversion rates, my key advice is to remember that every customer is different. Cater to individual needs and make the buying process as seamless as possible.

Staying updated with AI and analytics tools and leveraging personalization and predictive analysis can significantly improve your chances of converting browsers into buyers.”

Adopting SEO Strategies Naturally Build Traffic AND Conversions

Kevin Miller, a digital marketing expert and former Google employee, entrepreneur, angel investor, and “Entrepreneur of the Year” in the 2021 American Business Awards, says that optimizing the landing page and making some design improvements made a difference for his website.

Kevin Miller, Expert Round, Adopting SEO Strategies Naturally Build Traffic AND Conversions

“We’ve been running since 2020 trying to optimize lead generation through our website and other SEO efforts. A big change came with optimizing our landing page, which makes sense, where we added loud, orange CTAs to gather leads’ contact information and interest in our company.

Another significant strategy we used was adding a “Case Studies” page to our website. Users that visit and browse that page, primarily targeted users were significantly more likely to sign up for our email list or inquire about our services through our website.

The trouble is always trial and error, covering your bases and ensuring you’re marketing these techniques to the right audiences. Optimizing for SEO across your website and marketing strategies will naturally increase traffic and conversions. So stick to it, whatever you start with, and build your business one step at a time.” You can find out more about Kevin on

Conversion Rate Optimization Strategy: Multi-faceted approach 

David Cohen, the CEO of Badais International, the UK’s leading wholesale supplier of flowers and plants available for both delivery and click-and-collect says that they leveraged conversion rates by implementing a multi-faceted approach.

David Cohen, CEO of Badais International, Expert Round, Conversion Rate Optimization Strategy: Multi-faceted approach

“By leveraging AI-driven analytics, we identify customer behaviors and preferences to tailor personalized shopping experiences. By implementing personalized product recommendations and dynamic pricing,* we boost customer engagement and loyalty.

In a specific case study, we utilized an AI-powered chatbot to enhance customer support and engagement. The chatbot provided instant responses to inquiries, improving user experience and guiding customers through the purchase process. This led to a substantial 30% increase in conversions within a month.

During implementation, we faced challenges like* fine-tuning the chatbot’s responses and integrating it seamlessly into the website*. We overcame these hurdles by conducting continuous testing and refining the chatbot’s AI algorithms.

My advice for other eCommerce businesses is to invest in AI, analytics, and personalization tools. Understanding your customers and tailoring their experience can significantly boost conversions. Embrace innovative technologies to stay ahead in the competitive eCommerce landscape and continuously monitor performance to optimize strategies.”

Marketing Helps but Analytics is the King

Ryan Faber, a 15+ year marketing expert and a founder of Copymatic, an AI-powered platform that guides businesses in creating compelling and engaging content, says that the secret lies within the analysis.

Ryan Faber, founder of Copymatic, Expert Round, Marketing Helps but Analytics is the King

“We did a competitive marketing analysis first to see what our competitors were doing. I have learned through my experience as a marketer that it is wiser to adapt than to start from scratch, especially when you have limited resources. After the analysis, we found that more than the demographic, it is the content that needs to be studied.

Every social media platform has its own type of content that it favors. Like Instagram is all about reels, LinkedIn is about polls and picture stories. It helped us to navigate that it is not the content alone that matters but how the viewers there want to see it. And it did bring us positive results; we weren’t great, but we were doing better than before.”

Increase Conversion: Don’t forget the value proposition

Mike Hagley, digital PR lead at Carbar, a car subscription company that provides you with your own car, including insurance, rego, servicing, and assistance at the roadside, says that value proposition is what you need to pay attention to.
Mike Hagley, digital PR lead at Carbar, Expert Round, Increase Conversion: Don't forget the value proposition

“You can make a* value offer *that is both compelling and unambiguous to boost your conversion rate. The value proposition is the most crucial conversion aspect because it determines the eventuality of how quickly you convert.

When the initial step should really be concentrating on enhancing their value propositions, you can attempt to boost results by altering page components like font colors and sizes, icon shapes, graphics, incentives, and so on. You’re missing out if the only thing on your webpage is “Welcome!” or the title of your business or the item. Keep in mind that the value propositions for your business and your product are different. You need to address both things.”

Product descriptions are Crucial Part of Conversion Funnel

Jonathan Berenson, the owner of Two Tails Pet Company, which offers good-quality, functional, and well-designed pet accessories, shares the secret of reaching 2300+ five-star reviews on your products.

Jonathan Berenson, the owner of Two Tails Pet Company, Expert Round, Product descriptions are Crucial Part of Conversion Funnel

“I have gained vast knowledge about pets and how to meet customers’ expectations. Through my efficient conversion rate strategies, I have gained 2293 verified customer views for my brand.

Product descriptions are vital to attract customers. But the conversion rates get increased due to product benefits. Customers will buy your products only if they can gain advantages or fulfill their necessities. Thus, always highlight the benefits of your products on your eCommerce website. You can also write a promotional copy or creative blog emphasizing the product’s usefulness.

Convince your customers that buying your products will satisfy them for a long time. To prove the benefits of your products, you can also add verified reviews of your customers. They will build your authenticity and gain the trust of the target customers. Another way is including robust case studies.”

Wrapping It Up: Making Sense of Conversion Rate Optimization

Hey, you made it to the end! Let’s recap a bit. We’ve wandered through the intricate world of digital marketing, and hopefully, you’ve come out with a clearer understanding of the best practices for conversion. Truth be told, all the tips to increase your website conversion rate won’t mean much unless they resonate with real people—like you and me.

Marketing, at its core, is about connecting. It’s about understanding someone else’s needs, hopes, and maybe even dreams. The better our marketing efforts, the better we get at this. Add to that a dash of smooth UX, and you’re not just reaching out—you’re inviting in.

So, as you move forward, keep asking yourself: “Is this how I’d want to be approached?” It’s the human touch that makes all the difference, and for all the rest, you have SyncSpider. Integrate and automate all your tools without stress and boost your conversion rates sky-high. Best of luck with your endeavors, and remember—every click and every conversion starts with a genuine connection.

Get news about integrations and apps, every week

Talk to the Integration Expert

Unique business needs require unique solutions – We’re here to find them for you!

integrations aplications image